← Back to all briefings

Kashmir Clashes, Vatican Conclave, Red Sea Mishaps & Columbia Protests

May 8, 2025

Table of Contents

Key Updates

Kashmir Tinderbox: India and Pakistan Play with Fire (Again)

The situation between India and Pakistan has gone from simmering to a rolling boil, fast. Following the deadly attack on tourists in Pahalgam, Kashmir on April 22nd, which India predictably blamed on Pakistan, things have escalated dramatically. On May 7th, India launched military strikes, dubbed 'Operation Sindoor,' targeting what it claims are terrorist infrastructures within Pakistan. Pakistan, not one to take things lying down, claims to have shot down five Indian aircraft – a number that always needs a healthy dose of skepticism from either side in these situations – and has vowed significant retaliation, calling India's actions an 'act of war.'

This is, to put it mildly, not good. We're talking about two nuclear-armed states with a long and bloody history of conflict over Kashmir. The rhetoric is dialed up to eleven, with Narendra Modi's government in India making aggressive moves and Shehbaz Sharif in Pakistan promising a robust response. The international community is, as usual, wringing its hands and calling for restraint, but when has that ever stopped these two once they get going? The immediate concern is miscalculation. One side pushes, the other pushes back harder, and suddenly we’re staring into an abyss.

Analytical Take: This is classic South Asian brinkmanship, but with extremely high stakes. 'Operation Sindoor' sounds like a domestic play for Modi as much as a strategic one, projecting strength. Pakistan's claims of downing multiple aircraft are likely inflated for their own domestic audience and to signal capability. The real danger isn't necessarily a full-scale, planned nuclear exchange, but an escalatory spiral where conventional conflict gets out of hand, and the nuclear threshold becomes uncomfortably close. Keep an eye on troop movements and any further cross-border incidents. The global implications are huge, from regional stability to the potential for a sudden shock to global markets if this truly blows up.

Vatican Blues: No White Smoke Yet for a New Pope

The College of Cardinals is officially locked in, and the first puff of smoke from the Sistine Chapel on May 7th was black. No surprises there; these things rarely get settled on the first ballot, especially when the Church is navigating as many internal divisions and external pressures as it currently is. With Pope Francis having passed on April 21st, the 133 cardinal electors are now tasked with choosing his successor. The usual suspects are being bandied about, with names like Cardinals Luis Antonio Tagle and Robert Prevost in the mix, but the truth is, conclaves are notoriously opaque.

As reported previously, preparations for the conclave were underway following the Pope's death. Today's key development is the commencement of voting and the initial lack of a decision. The challenges awaiting the next Pontiff are significant: declining attendance in many Western nations, ongoing reverberations from clerical abuse scandals, and deep ideological divides within the Church itself on social issues and its future direction.

Analytical Take: Don't expect a quick resolution. The "era of Francis" brought a distinct pastoral and somewhat more progressive tone, which wasn't universally beloved within the more conservative wings of the Church. This election will be a litmus test for whether the cardinals want to continue that trajectory, consolidate, or even attempt a course correction. The talk of an African Pope is perennial, and while it would be symbolically potent, the underlying power structures in the Church are still very Euro-centric. The longer this goes on, the more it signals deep divisions.

Red Sea Blues: US Navy Loses Two Jets, Gains a Shaky Ceasefire

It’s been a rough week for the US Navy in the Red Sea. Two F/A-18 Super Hornets from the USS Harry S. Truman are now at the bottom of the sea. The first apparently just slid off the deck during towing operations – which sounds less like a combat loss and more like a very expensive oopsie. The second, on May 6th, crashed during landing due to an "arrestment failure," with both pilots thankfully ejecting with minor injuries. This follows yesterday's reporting that two jets were lost and the Houthi threat persisted.

The plot thickened considerably on May 6th when President Trump announced a ceasefire agreement with the Houthi rebels in Yemen. So, we're losing multi-million dollar aircraft to (seemingly) operational mishaps while simultaneously trying to de-escalate with the very group that’s been launching missiles and drones in the area. Interesting timing.

Analytical Take: The loss of two advanced fighter jets in non-combat situations within a week is, frankly, embarrassing and raises serious questions about operational tempo, maintenance, and crew training aboard the Truman. The Navy will be tight-lipped, but an investigation is undoubtedly in overdrive. The ceasefire with the Houthis is the bigger geopolitical story here. If it holds, it could represent a significant shift in the Yemen conflict and US involvement. However, Houthi agreements are notoriously fragile, and their Iranian backers might have opinions. Is the ceasefire a genuine breakthrough, or a tactical pause for both sides? The proximity of the jet losses to the ceasefire announcement is curious – perhaps unrelated, perhaps a catalyst for one side to de-escalate. One to watch closely.

Columbia University: From Protest to Police Action

The situation at Columbia University continues to escalate, moving beyond the campus funding cuts previously reported. On May 7th, pro-Palestinian protesters took over a section of the Butler Library, even renaming it the 'Basel Al-Araj Popular University' in a rather bold statement. This prompted the university administration, already under pressure from the Trump administration regarding alleged antisemitism and federal funding, to call in the NYPD. Multiple arrests followed.

The protesters are demanding divestment from Israel, a common theme in these campus actions. This particular incident, however, feels like a significant step up in terms of direct action and the university’s response. The backdrop includes the Trump administration freezing $400 million in grants to Columbia over antisemitism concerns earlier this year, adding a layer of federal pressure to the mix.

Analytical Take: This is a microcosm of a much larger, incredibly fraught debate. Columbia is caught between upholding free speech, ensuring campus safety, managing intense political pressure, and dealing with accusations of antisemitism. Calling in the NYPD is a sign that the university felt it had lost control, but it's also an action guaranteed to inflame tensions further and draw more national attention. This isn't just about Columbia; it's a bellwether for how universities nationwide will handle these deeply divisive protests. Expect more legal challenges, more political grandstanding, and unfortunately, probably more confrontations. The 'renaming' of the library, while symbolic, is a direct challenge to the university's authority that they couldn't ignore.

Tyre Nichols Case: State Acquittals Spark Outrage, Federal Charges Loom

A Memphis jury has acquitted three former police officers – Tadarrius Bean, Demetrius Haley, and Justin Smith – on all state charges, including second-degree murder, in the horrific death of Tyre Nichols in January 2023. Nichols died three days after being severely beaten during a traffic stop. The verdict, delivered May 7th, has, predictably, been met with outrage from Nichols' family and civil rights advocates.

It's crucial to note that these officers still face federal charges, and two other officers involved previously took plea deals. The defense argued about Nichols' behavior, and questions are being raised about the jury's composition (it was selected from Hamilton County, not Shelby where Memphis is).

Analytical Take: This verdict is a gut punch for those seeking police accountability through state courts. It underscores the immense difficulty in securing convictions against officers in use-of-force cases, even with graphic video evidence. The "he was resisting" defense, even when the resistance seems a desperate reaction to excessive force, often resonates with juries. The focus now shifts entirely to the federal civil rights charges, which have a different legal standard. This outcome will undoubtedly fuel more protests and intensify calls for police reform, while also emboldening those who argue that officers are unfairly targeted. It’s another stark reminder of the deep divisions in the US over policing and racial justice.

Trump's Policy Blitz: Trade Talks, Immigration Squeezes, and Budget Battles

The Trump administration remains a whirlwind of policy initiatives across multiple fronts, building on themes reported yesterday like budget infighting and trade tensions. Key developments today include Treasury Secretary Bessent announcing upcoming US-China trade talks in Switzerland, which feels like a slight de-escalation from the previous tariff threats. Simultaneously, there are reports of potential deportations to Libya – a new and rather alarming destination – and continued proposed cuts to Medicaid and the NIH. The administration is also still very much focused on antisemitism probes at universities, as seen with the Columbia situation. Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is apparently spearheading a 'Make America Healthy Again' initiative, while Kash Patel is defending the FBI's budget.

These moves are, as expected, drawing both fervent support and fierce opposition. President Trump is also expected to announce a major trade deal with Britain on May 8th, which will be interesting to dissect.

Analytical Take: This is classic Trump: keep multiple balls in the air, disrupt established norms, and cater to the base. The US-China talks in Switzerland suggest that perhaps the more aggressive tariff rhetoric was an opening bid for negotiation, though with this administration, a hardline stance could easily return. Deportations to Libya would be a significant and legally contentious escalation of immigration policy. The proposed cuts to Medicaid and NIH, alongside RFK Jr.'s involvement in health initiatives, signal a continued push for a radical reshaping of US healthcare and scientific research funding. The UK trade deal will be trumpeted as a win, but the devil, as always, will be in the details and what concessions were made. This flurry of activity keeps opponents off balance and energizes supporters, but the long-term coherence and impact of these disparate policies remain to be seen.

REAL ID Day Arrives: So Far, More Whimper Than Bang at Airports

The long-dreaded, much-delayed REAL ID Act enforcement for domestic air travel officially kicked in on May 7th. As previously noted, concerns were high about airport chaos. For now, reports suggest a relatively smooth transition at many airports, though the TSA is bracing for potential issues as more travelers encounter the new rules. Adults now need a REAL ID-compliant driver's license or another acceptable form of identification, like a passport, to get through security.

The lead-up saw a surge in demand at DMVs, creating backlogs. The core debate continues: is this a necessary security enhancement or an infringement on privacy and freedom of travel, creating a de facto internal passport?

Analytical Take: The "smooth transition" might be a bit premature. The real test will come during peak travel periods and as more people who haven't updated their IDs try to fly. Expect some horror stories of missed flights and long secondary screening lines to emerge. The underlying constitutional questions haven't gone away, but for now, the focus is on compliance and enforcement. This is a massive logistical undertaking, and the true impact on travel patterns and DMV operations will only become clear over the coming months. It’s another layer of friction in the travel process, and whether the security benefits outweigh the costs and inconvenience is still very much an open question.

Kashmir Clashes, Vatican Conclave, Red Sea Mishaps & Columbia Protests | The Updates